Impact: The Great Gatsby

The Man Who Wanted Too Much

Francis Scott Key Fitzgerald was born in 1896 in St. Paul, Minnesota, to a family that occupied an uncomfortable position in the social world: genteel enough to have aspirations, not wealthy enough to fulfill them. His father was a failed businessman; his mother's money kept the family afloat. Fitzgerald grew up acutely aware of the distance between the life he imagined and the life he had — a sensitivity that would define everything he ever wrote.

He went to Princeton, dropped out to join the Army, and while stationed in Alabama met Zelda Sayre, the daughter of a prominent judge and the most dazzling person he had ever encountered. Zelda initially refused to marry him because he had no money. He went home and rewrote his first novel, This Side of Paradise, sold it, and she said yes. The dynamic — the poor boy transforming himself to win the golden girl — is not merely a theme in The Great Gatsby. It is autobiography, thinly transposed.

By the time he wrote Gatsby, Fitzgerald and Zelda were living on the French Riviera, burning through money at a spectacular rate, and Fitzgerald was already beginning to understand that the glittering world he had fought so hard to enter was not what he had imagined from the outside. He was thirty years old. He had seen enough to write the novel that would outlast everything else he did.

A Quiet Landing

Fitzgerald knew The Great Gatsby was something extraordinary. 'I think it's the best thing I've done so far,' he wrote to his editor Maxwell Perkins in the months before publication, with an unusual certainty. His previous novel, The Beautiful and Damned, had sold well but felt sprawling and unresolved. Gatsby was different — lean, controlled, every image doing double work.

The reviews in 1925 were largely admiring but oddly muted. Critics praised the prose and expressed vague reservations about the characters — too shallow, too superficial, not the kind of people readers could care about. This missed the point almost entirely, since Fitzgerald was writing about shallow and superficial people on purpose, and the tragedy was precisely that we do care about them despite ourselves. Sales were modest. A stage adaptation flopped. A silent film version in 1926 has been almost entirely lost.

Fitzgerald spent the rest of his life measuring himself against the book and finding himself wanting. He died in Hollywood in 1940, working on a novel about a movie producer, widely considered a cautionary tale about a brilliant writer who had wasted himself on drink and celebrity. His obituaries were not unkind, but they were elegiac in the wrong way — they mourned a promising career rather than celebrating a masterpiece. At the time of his death, The Great Gatsby was out of print.

How a War Made It a Classic

The resurrection of The Great Gatsby is one of the stranger stories in American literary history, and it was driven by the United States military. During World War II, the Council of Books in Wartime — a government initiative designed to provide reading material to American troops — distributed cheap paperback editions of approved novels to soldiers overseas. The Great Gatsby was among them. Hundreds of thousands of copies went out to men who had time to read and no particular prejudice about what the critics had said in 1925.

Those soldiers came home, went to college on the GI Bill, and their professors assigned the book. By the 1950s, The Great Gatsby had become a standard text in American high schools and universities. By the 1960s, it was canonical. Today it sells roughly 500,000 copies per year — more annually than it sold in Fitzgerald's entire lifetime. It is one of the most widely assigned novels in American education, which means it is also one of the most widely resented by teenagers who were forced to analyze the green light at the end of Daisy's dock before they were old enough to understand why it hurts.

What the Book Is Actually About

On the surface, The Great Gatsby is about a mysterious millionaire named Jay Gatsby who throws legendary parties at his mansion on Long Island, all in the hope of reuniting with a woman named Daisy Buchanan whom he loved five years earlier before he had money. It is narrated by Daisy's cousin Nick Carraway, a Yale man newly arrived from the Midwest to make his fortune in the bond business. This sounds like a romantic plot, possibly even a comedy. It is not.

The novel is a precisely engineered critique of the American mythology of self-invention. Gatsby was born James Gatz, the son of poor farmers in North Dakota. He has spent years fabricating an identity — the Oxford background, the inherited wealth, the English shirts ordered in such quantities they overflow his wardrobe. Nick's first description of him is unforgettable: a man with 'an extraordinary gift for hope, a romantic readiness such as I have never found in any other person.' Gatsby's faith in his own reinvention is absolute and, Fitzgerald suggests, entirely American.

But the novel is just as interested in the people Gatsby is trying to join as in Gatsby himself. Tom and Daisy Buchanan are 'careless people,' Nick concludes — 'they smashed up things and creatures and then retreated back into their money or their vast carelessness.' The old money of East Egg looks down on Gatsby's new money from West Egg, and neither notices the ash heaps in between, where the working poor live under the faded billboard eyes of Doctor T. J. Eckleburg, an oculist's advertisement that looms over the Valley of Ashes like a blind and indifferent god. The symbolism is heavy, but Fitzgerald earns it because the prose around it is so precise.

And then there is Nick himself — one of the most subtly unreliable narrators in American fiction. He opens the book by declaring his own tolerance and reserve. 'I'm inclined to reserve all judgements,' he announces, before proceeding to judge everyone in the novel with remarkable consistency. He is charmed by Gatsby, complicit in his schemes, and watching from the margins as everything collapses. Whether Nick is a moral center or simply a man who mistakes observation for innocence is a question the book never fully resolves — and probably shouldn't.

The Sentences Themselves

It would be a mistake to write about The Great Gatsby without saying something about what it actually feels like to read the prose, because the prose is a significant part of the argument. Fitzgerald wrote in a style that was lyrical without being precious, melancholy without being sentimental, and exact in ways that only become apparent when you go back and try to identify how he achieved a particular effect.

The famous closing lines — about boats against the current, borne back ceaselessly into the past — are quoted so often they have lost some of their force. But the quieter sentences reward attention. Nick's description of Gatsby at his own parties, 'watching over nothing,' standing apart from the spectacle he has created; the moment when Gatsby and Daisy finally reunite and the dream becomes real enough to be disappointing; Tom Buchanan's ugly, restless energy filling every room he enters. Fitzgerald understood that the most devastating emotional revelations arrive in specific, almost offhand detail. The green light. The pink suit. The shirts.

A Hundred Years of Gatsby

The novel has been adapted for film four times, most famously in 1974 with Robert Redford and Mia Farrow, and in 2013 with Leonardo DiCaprio and a Baz Luhrmann-directed spectacle that divided critics but broke box office records. Neither fully captured the book, which is perhaps the point — the gap between the dream and the reality is the book's central subject, and adaptations keep discovering that gap firsthand.

Beyond film, The Great Gatsby has saturated American culture in ways both expected and strange. The phrase 'old sport,' Gatsby's affected greeting, has become shorthand for a particular kind of performed gentility. Jay-Z's 2013 album Magna Carta Holy Grail engages directly with Gatsby's mythology. Kanye West has cited the novel. Themed Gatsby parties, complete with flapper costumes and jazz bands, are a cottage industry. The book has inspired everything from serious literary fiction to real estate marketing copy for luxury condominiums.

More substantively, The Great Gatsby established a template that American fiction has returned to repeatedly: the observer-narrator who gains access to a glamorous and dangerous world, the self-made man whose rise conceals a ruinous obsession, the critique of wealth dressed as a celebration of it. You can trace a direct line from Gatsby to Salinger, to Cheever, to Don DeLillo, to the social novels of Tom Wolfe. The party scenes in Bonfire of the Vanities, the unreliable narrators of countless literary thrillers — Fitzgerald's fingerprints are everywhere.

Why It Still Stings

The reason The Great Gatsby survives as more than a school assignment is that its central question has not aged. Can a person remake themselves entirely? Can you escape the circumstances of your birth through sheer force of will and enough money? America has always answered yes, emphatically and with advertising. Fitzgerald's answer is more complicated: yes, you can remake yourself, but you cannot choose what you become, and the dream you are chasing was always someone else's idea of what you should want.

Gatsby's tragedy is not that he fails to win Daisy. It is that winning Daisy was never actually the point — the point was the five-year dream of winning her, the green light across the water, the future that existed only because it hadn't happened yet. 'Can't repeat the past?' Gatsby asks Nick, incredulous. 'Why of course you can!' He is wrong, and he cannot imagine being wrong, and that gap between his certainty and the reality is where the whole novel lives.

Read at sixteen, the book tends to feel like a sad story about rich people. Read at thirty, it starts to feel like a warning you received too late. That shift — the experience of returning to a book and finding that it has changed while you were gone — is one of the surest measures of whether a novel is worth reading at all. The Great Gatsby passes that test every time.

Further Reading & Resources

Related Works in Our Library